Beyond The Near

And it Just Continues

June 21st, 2006 by Azadi

I thought I was done. Guess what?

I saw this on my Google page.

“An investigation that refuses to look at contradictory evidence can hardly be considered credible,” said Marc Garlasco, senior military analyst at Human Rights Watch.

“The IDF’s partisan approach highlights the need for an independent, international investigation.”

Israel has ruled out an international probe.

The army has said shelling of the area, in response to rocket fire into the Jewish state, had ended before the beach blast. Retrieved shrapnel samples also ruled out the possibility of a direct Israeli artillery barrage, it said.

As I mentioned before, I’m inclined to believe at least the sincerity of the Israeli claims that it was not their rockets that day that hit the civilians on the beach. A false denial would serve no one, considering Israel’s history of owning up to and apologizing for her botches, and also considering the fact that no one believes Israelis anyway, except when they admit guilt. Israel is condemned regardless, so if the Israeli military believed that the civilian deaths were, in fact, a result of the shelling, what is the point in denying it?

But what really interested me was the assertion that “Israel has ruled out an international probe.” Because last I heard

An Israeli foreign ministry official said no request had been received from the UN to conduct an inquiry, but said Israel would co-operate if one were received. “We have nothing to hide,” he said.

So which is it? Who can we turn to to give us accurate news? Not that I look to Al-Jazeera for impartial reporting any day, but I’d like it if someone would just provide some factual information, at the very least about who said what and when. Is that really so hard to do?

Ultimately though, I mean, realistically, lets be honest about this:

Who gives a fuck?

Something terrible happened. Innocents died on a beach from an explosion. The explosion may have been caused by a number of things, including a shell from Israeli artillary. Israel shells Gaza. Israel shells Gaza because Gaza fires rockets at Israel. Is Gaza condemned for this? Yes, from many sides. But no one is “outraged” anymore by what the Palestinians do to and in Israel. No one is outraged because they’ve been doing it for so long and everyone is used to it. They come to expect it of the Palestinians. They’ve been so tenacious in their campaign of guerrilla warfare that the international community has grown so bored with the Palestinians that when they attack Israel is as though nothing has happened. Just another day, nothing special, nothing worth noting.

In such a climate, what ends up happening is that Israel’s retaliation looks out of the blue. Do the Palestinians concern themselves with whether or not they kill civilians? No, every Israeli death is a victory for them, and the world clucks their tongues and says “gee, that’s awful.” If Israel retaliates and kills militants, it’s looked at with ambivalence by the international community and outrage by Arabs. If Israel retaliates and unintentionally kills civilians, the world is outraged… and Hamas celebrates the outrage.

The persistence of Palestinian hostilities does not mean that they are right. The fact that they are willing to fight until Israel is detroyed does not mean that Israel should be destroyed so that the fighting will stop. Sometimes I really feel that this is what people think and, I can’t help it, it makes me very very angry.

Posted in Israel, News |

3 Responses

  1. Ryan Murphy Says:

    I wish I knew more about what daily life was like over there. It seems like it must be hard for both sides at this point. Terrorist attacks create an almost constant sense of unease for innocent Israelis, while their (justified) protectivity leads to cruel hardships for innocent Palestinians, who perhaps have to cross security checkpoints every day to go to school. It may also be important to note the poverty of the Palestinian people. I don’t know the extent of this poverty, but I do imagine that a typical life in Palestine is more difficult than a typical life in Israel. Do you think that things like security checkpoints get in the way of Palestinian attempts to form a viable economy? It must be very difficult to establish healthy trade relations.

  2. cb Says:

    Hi Azadi,

    I just saw a post of yours at Dr. Helen’s. You might want to try this site, if you haven’t already.

    neo-neocon.blogspot.com

    She is a post 9/11 ex-Democrat still surrounded by Democrats.

  3. Azadi Says:

    Ryan,

    I wish I knew more about daily life there too. I want very badly to live in Israel for some period of time before I apply to rabbinical school here in New York. But knowing people over there, I do know a little bit about what goes on.

    My opinion about the economic predicament of the Palestinians is that it is an outrage… but not an outrage perpetrated by Israel. The Palestinian Territories are at active war with Israel, and as such, Israel should have no responsibility to them. It is the Arab world that has royally fucked the Palestinian people, and the Palestinian leadership persists in keeping them fucked by funneling nearly all money that goes into the Palestinian economy into weapons and terrorist training camps rather than infrastructure, education, healthcare, housing, etc. The Palestinian refugee camps were created by the Arab world and it is the Arab world’s responsibility to rectify the situation. The fact is that they refuse to do so because the image of the poor Palestinians is such a potent political tool against Israel that they would rather see their fellow Arabs suffer and turn world opinion against Israel than actually create livable and even prosperous conditions for the Palestinian people and have Jews in what they consider to be Islamic Empire property. I think that the checkpoints are a necessary result of the cruelty of the Arab nations toward the Palestinians, who are used as a pawn in their war against Israel and the Jews, between whom they see no distinction.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.